Obama Re-Writes History, Clinches Party Nomination
MICHEL MARTIN, host:
I'm Michel Martin, and this is Tell Me More from NPR News. Just ahead, four attractive young people, a camera crew, a luxury RV - yes it's a reality show, but with a twist. Four young Arabs go on a road trip to discover America. We'll tell you what they find out. And our series on investing continues.
But first, the longest running presidential primary in memory comes to an end, and it's official. Senator Barack Obama is the presumptive Democratic nominee, becoming the first African-American to win a major party nomination. His presumed Republican opponent Senator John McCain wasted no time in taking up the fight. He gave a speech that took aim at Obama's experience and philosophy. Meanwhile, Obama's erstwhile opponent Senator Hillary Clinton refused to concede. Here to give us a bit of perspective on it all are the two women we've been turning to throughout the last few months. Sara Taylor, a Republican strategist, former director of political affairs for President Bush, and Stephanie Cutter, Democratic strategist and communications director for Senator John Kerry's 2004 White House run. Welcome back to you both.
Ms. SARA TAYLOR (Republican Strategist, Former Director of Political Affairs for President Bush): Welcome, thank you.
Ms. STEPHANIE CUTTER (Democratic Strategist, Communications Director for Senator John Kerry's 2004 White House Presidential Campaign): Good to be here.
MARTIN: Stephanie, let me start with you because this is a Democratic night. You've had a front row seat for a lot of big events. Watching last night, did it feel historic?
Ms. CUTTER: Well, you know, Michel, it did. You know, it's hard to remember where we started just, you know, 15 months ago. Back then nobody thought it would be possible for Barack Obama to win the party's nomination. Last night was a real turning point not just for the Democratic Party but for the country and amidst the ongoing competition that went on between Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton and the jabs that went back and forth between Barack Obama and John McCain. I think it's important for everybody to realize just how historic last night was.
MARTIN: Sara, what about you? I know you're not a Democrat, but…
Ms. TAYLOR: Not a Democrat, but it was a historic night for the country and, you know, certainly the Democrats, you have to give them credit. Their frontrunners and now nominee, you know, the first African-American, the first woman, and that's a good thing for the country. And we may not agree with their policies, and we'll have a passionate debate about why they're not right to lead the country, but it does show you how far America has come in the last few decades.
MARTIN: Stephanie, a lot of interesting symbolism all night. Obama appeared on the same stage in St. Paul, Minnesota where John McCain will accept the Republican party's nomination in September. What was the idea behind that, and was it a good one in your opinion?
Ms. CUTTER: I think that yes, it was a good idea. It really sets up the choice in this election. That in just a mere number of months, Republicans are going to be coming together across the country to celebrate their nominee John McCain and, you know, last night is where our nominee was accepting - finally crossed the hurdle of the number of delegates he needs to be our party's nominee. It sets up the choice. If you look at the words in both Barack Obama and John McCain's speeches, it really set up a generational fight. McCain kept referring to Barack Obama as his young opponent, and Barack Obama kept discussing some of the policies that have gone wrong over the past eight years and why it's really a time for change. So I don't think the choice could become any more crystal clear between Barack Obama and John McCain, and as Sara said we will have a full robust debate over the coming months. And I think both parties are anxious for it.
MARTIN: We'll talk about John McCain in just a minute because I want to play a little bit of his speech, but I want to pause on that for just a minute and talk a little bit about Senator Clinton. Let's play a short clip of what she had to say.
Senator HILLARY CLINTON (Democrat, New York): This has been a long campaign, and I will be making no decisions tonight, but this has always been your campaign. I hope you'll go to my website at hillaryclinton.com and share your thoughts with me and help in any way that you can.
MARTIN: So, Stephanie, why is she doing this? There is no way, short of lightning striking, that she can be the nominee at this point. What is the point?
Ms. CUTTER: Well, nobody knows exactly the point except for Hillary Clinton, but a lot of us are assuming that she's just maintaining her political leverage. What does she want out of it? It's unclear at this point. It could be the vice-presidential slot, it could be retiring some of her debt, it could be having to do with some of her policy proposals. We don't really know, but it's clear that she is trying to maintain some political leverage in the waning days of the nominating contest. You know, she got tens of millions of votes - 17 million people came out and voted for her. She won a number of states. You know, she's earned the right for at least a couple more days to figure out how she wants to end this race, but I think Democrats are anxious to bring this contest to an end so that we can focus our sights on John McCain and winning the White House. And it's important for both Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, and all of their supporters, to end this in the right way.
MARTIN: If you're just joining us, you're listening to Tell Me More from NPR News, and I'm talking politics with Democratic strategist Stephanie Cutter and Republican strategist Sara Taylor about last night's events. Senator Barack Obama clinching the Democratic nomination and making history as the first African-American to win a major party bid. Sara, some Democrats have been calling an Obama-Clinton picket a dream ticket. Do you think it is?
Ms. TAYLOR: Well, I think that he's going to have to take a hard look at her given how close the contest was depending upon how you slice the numbers. You know, she may or may not be ahead in the popular vote. There's still superdelegates who haven't yet voiced their support for a candidate.
MARTIN: I'm sorry. I just only have to clarify because we've talked so much about this. She's only ahead in the popular vote if you discount all the caucus states.
Ms. TAYLOR: That's right.
MARTIN: So - which I don't know. I don't know - all those people who stood in the snow in Iowa feel about that, but anyway, go ahead.
Ms. TAYLOR: But she - well, but, you know, she also has won very significant states that Barack Obama is going to need to win if he's going to be elected, and if you look at Pennsylvania and Iowa and Florida, even though he didn't campaign there, you know, she did well in those states. She has a very strong and important coalition for Democrats to win which is, you know, working class whites who, you know, tend to be historic, historically have been swing voters in elections, and so for any Democrat to win they need to do well and in a down economy, Democrats are poised to do well with that group. That's a group, though, that has supported Hillary Clinton very strongly. That's a coalition he's going to need to be able to speak to if he's going to be elected, so you can certainly make a case if you're a Hillary Clinton supporter as to why she makes a lot of sense for him. Only he can decide that. He's got to be comfortable with her. He's got to be able to pick up the phone and have a trusting relationship. And it's been a very bitter fight, so it strikes me as being pretty hard to put that together at the end of the day.
MARTIN: What about from a Republican standpoint? Would you enjoy running against that ticket or not?
Ms. TAYLOR: Well, you know, certainly there's very few things that they don't agree on candidly, so I think, you know, running against the nominee is really what matters because people are going to cast their ballot for the nominee, not the vice president. The vice president can certainly add some qualities to the ticket, but you know, Barack Obama, there's a lot to distinguish with between Senator McCain and Barack Obama, particularly on foreign policy, but also on domestic issues and so, you know, Republicans are going to have plenty to point to.
MARTIN: Stephanie, what about you? Dream ticket or not?
Ms. CUTTER: Well, if I could just go back to a couple of things that Sara said. In terms of Barack Obama's appeal to working-class voters, Barack Obama is getting the same amount, if not more, of those working-class voters than any other Democratic nominee. Now in a Democratic primary, between Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama, the majority of them chose Hillary Clinton, but it is wrong to think that in a choice between Barack Obama and John McCain that all of those people are going to flock to John McCain, particularly when the economy is the numbe-one issue in the country, and 90 percent of the American people think the economy is going in the wrong direction. So, it's just a false argument that we are hearing over and over again from Republicans that he's going to have a problem with white voters. Now, the other thing, in terms of whether a Clinton-Barack Obama ticket, would be a dream ticket? It's not really comparable to tickets of the past because we've never had someone like Hillary Clinton in the number two spot. I mean she did get 17 million votes. She does have enormous name recognition. There are people across the country who have come out in waves to support her. So, it's not comparable to vice-presidential tickets in the past because you know, normally those people don't have the same name recognition, and you pick them for particular political purposes, like winning a particular state, or balancing the ticket on a particular issue.
MARTIN: I do want to say one - I'm sorry to interrupt Stephanie, I just wanted to save a couple of minutes to talk about Senator McCain who I think, you know, kind of - made kind of an in-your-face move last night by scheduling a big speech even before Senator Obama had taken the stage. I wanted to play a clip, but since we are sort of short on time, just wanted to ask if this was a show case moment - with very mixed reviews today about his performance. Sara, what did you think? Did you think that he took advantage of that opportunity?
Ms. TAYLOR: Well, look, I think what you see - it's - the general race has started. John McCain, you know, has a significant disagreements with him, particularly with foreign policy and you know, he set out right last night, and you know we have a very short time between now and the conventions and ultimately now and November. And he's going to not waste any days in making this debate.
MARTIN: I know, but reading the speech is one thing and seeing it is another. And a lot of people talked about his demeanor. They said his performance seemed flat in contrast to the kind of inspirational soaring moment represented by the Democrats. That he just - he didn't seem very energized?
Ms. TAYLOR: Well, you know, I don't know if I would say he wasn't energized. I think it was probably the difference in venue. And look, this was Barack Obama's nomination moment, and he was surrounded by 15,000 people, and John McCain was in New Orleans and did a smaller event. So, you know, really what matters is the substance of what they are saying. And as Senator McCain pointed out yesterday is he's going to draw a big contrast between, you know, being able to be a reformer and being somebody who says he's for change for the sake of change. And I think that, you know, if you look Barack Obama's positions on meeting with terrorist nations which is a - going to be a huge, huge point of contention in this debate and something that Americans I think take stock in when they vote for president.
MARTIN: OK, to be continued. Stephanie, we have about 30 seconds left, and I just cannot let you go without asking you - because you are joining us from North Carolina, where you've been assisting the Kennedy family and dealing with all the issues surrounding Senator Ted Kennedy's surgery. Can you just give us a brief update on how he's doing?
Ms. CUTTER: Oh, thanks. He's doing great. The doctors couldn't be more pleased with how the surgery went on Monday. And you know, he's the same old Ted Kennedy and up and walking around the hospital, looking to go home as soon as possible. You know, he's going to take this fight on like he's taken everything on in life, with vigor and strength.
Ms. CUTTER: So, it's great to be down here - to be with him, and to have worked with him and to call him my friend.
MARTIN: All right.
Ms. CUTTER: It's a real honor.
MARTIN: All right. Well, thank you for that. Stephanie Cutter, Democratic strategist, joined us by phone from North Carolina. Sara Taylor, Republican strategist, was kind enough to join us in our Washington Studio. Ladies, once again, thank you.
Ms. TAYLOR: Thank you. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.