Dan Maffei, the cerebral Democrat and perennial candidate

Oct 30, 2014

As WRVO profiles congressional races in central and northern New York this week, we turn to the 24th Congressional District. It features a well-known Democrat who has struggled to hold onto the office, and a political neophyte. We begin first with our profile of the incumbent, Rep. Dan Maffei.

Maffei has spent the better part of the last decade running for Congress. He’s lost, won, lost, won and now, at 46 years old, he’s running for re-election.

Maffei grew up in the district’s epicenter, Syracuse, in the city’s Westcott neighborhood. He spent his early adult life as a local TV reporter and then congressional staff member for two U.S. senators and a representative.

He would make the switch from staffer to politician when he decided to run against longtime Republican Rep. Jim Walsh in 2006. It started with a lunch meeting with a childhood friend. 

"And he actually said to me, Jim Walsh isn’t doing a good job representing our home district; someone should go and run against him," said Bruce Andrews, who grew up with Maffei on Allen Street. "And he said, ‘one of us should do it.’ And I said, ‘Dan, I think you should do it.’" 

Maffei recalled his motivations for running the first time a few years later in an interview with WRVO’s "Campbell Conversations."

"I just really felt that we needed a change and that President Bush’s policies had taken us down the wrong road and Congressman Walsh, for whatever political or personal reasons, felt he had to continue supporting them," he said.

In and out of office

Rep. Dan Maffei discussing the I-81 viaduct project. (File photo)
Credit Ryan Delaney / WRVO

Maffei fell 3,000 votes short of upsetting Walsh, but it left Maffei poised for another run two years later. When Walsh retired, Maffei mounted a second campaign. 

He won, beating Onondaga County Legislator Dale Sweetland, thanks in part to strong Democratic voter turnout in support of Barack Obama’s first presidential run. 

But Maffei would only serve one term. He lost by 648 votes to conservative Republican Ann Marie Buerkle in a very close race that drew last-minute national attention.

Maffei went into hibernation after that. Four months after Election Day, he gave his first interview to WRVO.

"I know I was a very good congressman," Maffei said. "Perhaps a really good congressman, given the seniority, but maybe I am too cerebral to be a candidate."

He wouldn’t commit to another run for Congress just yet. 

"I took the loss very hard, maybe too hard."

"You know, I took the loss very hard, maybe too hard," said Maffei. "Maybe people who take it to heart too much shouldn’t be in this game."

Maffei spent the two years in between his congressional terms working for a Washington think tank, Third Way, and teaching at the SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry in Syracuse.

He ultimately decided to try and win his seat back.

"He chose to do it because I think he felt he would be letting down his supporters. There was clearly no one else who would be as good as him or be a challenge to the opponent," said Rhea Jezer, a former Onondaga County Democratic Party official who ran for Congress unsuccessfully twice in the 90’s.

Carry a ticket?

Maffei squared off again with Buerkle. It became one of the most expensive and contentious races the region has ever seen. In 2012, with President Obama up for re-election, Maffei was able to reclaim his spot in the House of Representatives.

Former President Bill Clinton with Rep. Dan Maffei. (File photo)
Credit Ellen Abbott / WRVO

Needing Obama on the ballot has showed Maffei’s inability to rally Democratic voters in central New York.

He’s been criticized again this year for running a negative campaign against a new Republican challenger, former federal prosecutor John Katko. 

Vice President Joe Biden and former President Bill Clinton have both stumped for Maffei in the campaign’s final days. Obama won’t be on the ballot Tuesday, so voter turnout will be up to Maffei. 

In interviews with WRVO, fellow elected Democrats, supporters and party strategists describe Maffei as a policy and issues-driven lawmaker, more than a back-slapping politician. That has at times caused Maffei to come off as more nerdy than cordial or personable.

"I would go along with Dan coming across a little nerdy at times, but I don’t think he’s aloof. Especially when you meet him, he’s very warm and listens to people," countered Democratic state Assemblyman Bill Magnarelli. 

"He's very warm and listens to people."

Maffei, for his part, admits a nerdy side. 

Lack of influence

Supporters describe Maffei as someone who works hard and is an advocate for central New Yorkers, but not always influential. Maffei’s in-and-out of office streak, said Dr. Dennis Nave, president of the Greater Syracuse Labor Council, has left him weaker than his predecessor.  

"I think having been an incumbent and lost an election, in all honesty, I think it definitely hurt his influence and he probably didn’t get the seniority in Congress we would of hoped for," Nave said.

Several other central New York Democrats, both in office and recently out, were reluctant to discuss Maffei’s time as a congressman and his campaign with WRVO. Others declined interviews outright, or didn’t respond to requests.

Rep. Dan Maffei, D-Syracuse. (File photo)
Credit Ryan Delaney / WRVO

Among those declining an interview was Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner, a prominent Democrat. She’s previously been critical of the tone the campaign has taken this year.

"I still pinch myself"

Onondaga County Executive Joanie Mahoney, a Republican who rebelled against her own party to twice endorse Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo, is backing Katko in this race. She says she’s not negative Maffei and has been able to work well with him.

"He has lost campaigns and come back, so I think he understands probably better than most the difference between the politics and then actually doing the job," she said in an interview.

Late in his first term as a congressman, Maffei told "Campbell Conversations" being elected is one of his most surprising achievements.

"The son of a couple of social workers, of divorced parents, from Syracuse, who went to Nottingham High School and now I’m a member of Congress," he said, "I still pinch myself."

Tomorrow, we will profile Republican challenger John Katko.